renovate house or knock down and rebuild?



Deciding whether to renovate an existing house or knock it down and build a new one can be challenging. This decision depends on various factors, including the condition of the existing structure, your budget, and your long-term plans. This article explores the key considerations, advantages, and disadvantages of both options and provides essential information on VAT exemptions for new build homes in the UK.

demolish and rebuild or refurbish

Factors to consider

rebuild or renovate?



  • Cost
    It can actually cost less to rebuild with the VAT savings available
  • Time
    Work on existing buildings is time consuming and unpredictable
  • Improvement
    A new building will have more options to suit your requirements
  • Environment
    Keeping the existing building will have a lower carbon footprint


Deciding whether to demolish or renovate

current condition of the house


Structural Integrity

The structural integrity of your existing home is a crucial factor in deciding whether to renovate or rebuild. Significant issues such as foundation problems, extensive damp, or structural damage may make renovation impractical and costly.


Age and Layout

Older homes may have outdated layouts that don’t suit modern living needs. Narrow hallways, small rooms, and lack of open-plan spaces might prompt a complete rebuild to create a more functional and aesthetically pleasing design.


Historical or Listed Buildings

If your home is a listed building or has historical significance, you may face restrictions on alterations. In such cases, extensive renovation might be the only option, although it can be more complex and expensive.

New Build vs Renovation

Cost Considerations


Renovation Costs

Renovation costs can vary widely based on the extent of the work required. Minor updates such as painting, flooring, and new fixtures are relatively affordable. However, significant renovations involving structural changes, extensions, or modernizations can be expensive.


Rebuild Costs

Rebuilding a house from scratch involves significant initial costs, including demolition, design, planning permissions, and construction. However, new builds benefit from modern construction techniques, energy efficiency, and tailored design, which can offer long-term savings and increased property value.


Budget and Financing

Assess your budget and financing options. Renovations can often be funded through savings or home improvement loans. For new builds, you might need a larger mortgage or construction loan. Consider the potential return on investment for both options.


VAT Exemption on New Build Homes

One significant financial advantage of building a new home is the VAT exemption on most construction costs. New build homes are typically zero-rated for VAT, meaning you don’t pay VAT on labor and materials, which can result in substantial savings.


New Build VAT Exemption Eligibility Criteria

To qualify for VAT exemption, your new build must meet specific criteria:

  • The property must be a new dwelling, not a converted or renovated structure.
  • It must be for residential use, not commercial.
  • You must have obtained all necessary planning permissions.


Claiming VAT Refunds

If you’re managing the construction yourself, you can reclaim VAT on some of the materials used. Keep detailed records and receipts of all purchases and consult HMRC guidelines to ensure you meet the requirements for a VAT refund.


Time and Disruption


Renovation Timeline

Renovations can vary in duration based on the project’s complexity. Small updates may take a few weeks, while extensive renovations can span several months. Renovation projects can be disruptive, especially if you need to live in the house during the work.


Rebuild Timeline

Rebuilding a house is a more extended process, often taking a year or more from planning to completion. During this period, you’ll need alternative accommodation, adding to the overall cost and inconvenience.

What Planning Approvals Are Needed?

planning permission


Renovation Permissions

Renovations usually require fewer permissions than new builds, but significant changes may still need planning permission. It’s essential to consult with your local planning authority and ensure all necessary approvals are obtained before starting work.


Planning Permission for New Builds

Building a new home requires comprehensive planning permission. This process involves submitting detailed plans, meeting building regulations, and sometimes conducting environmental impact assessments. It can be time-consuming and requires meticulous planning.


Pros and Cons, renovation vs rebuilding



Pros of renovation

  • Lower Initial Costs:
    Renovations often require less upfront investment compared to rebuilding.
  • Preserving Character:
    You can retain the unique character and charm of an older home.
  • Less Disruption:
    Renovations can be less disruptive if you can stay in the house during the work.

Cons of renovation

  • Unforeseen Issues:
    Renovations can uncover unexpected problems, increasing costs and timelines.
  • Limited Layout Changes:
    Structural limitations may restrict how much you can change the layout.
  • Potentially Higher Maintenance:
    Older homes may require more ongoing maintenance.


Pros and Cons, renovation vs rebuilding



Pros of Rebuilding

  • Custom Design:
    A new build allows for a completely custom design tailored to your needs.
  • Energy Efficiency:
    Modern construction techniques result in more energy-efficient homes.
  • Long-Term Value:
    New homes often have higher resale value and lower maintenance costs.

Cons of Rebuilding

  • Higher Initial Costs:
    The upfront costs of demolition and construction are significant.
  • Longer Timeline:
    Building a new home takes longer than renovating an existing one.
  • Planning Complexity:
    Obtaining planning permission and meeting regulations can be complex and time-consuming.



renovate or rebuild


Deciding whether to renovate or knock down and build a new home in the UK involves carefully weighing the condition of your existing property, budget, time, and long-term goals. Renovations can be less expensive and less disruptive but may come with limitations and unexpected issues. Rebuilding offers a fresh start with a custom design and modern efficiency but requires substantial investment and time.

Consider the potential VAT exemption on new build homes, which can offer significant financial benefits. Consult with professionals, including architects, builders, and financial advisors, to make an informed decision that best suits your needs and circumstances. By thoroughly evaluating your options, you can achieve the home of your dreams while maximizing value and efficiency.

More Guidance

all posts

We have written a number of posts which provide information and guidanceto anyone considering a project. These include advice on design and planning of new homes, renovations and extensions.



If you have a project you would like to discuss with us then just drop us a line using this form and we will get back to you. Or call us in our London studio on 020 3920 9805.

We will be happy to help and we look forward to hearing from you.



+44 (0)20 3920 9805


45 Dresden Rd, London, N19